Are Sitka Salmon Shares any good? Updated 2021

Deal alert: use code GSLC over on the Sitka website for $25 off a premium seafood share. We get a referral fee too :)

I first heard about Sitka Salmon Shares when the Alaskan based brand reached out for me to review their product; so full disclosure up front, the company sent me a little sample of their product in the mail to test. I’m so glad they did, I intend to be a paying customer for a long time now!

The idea behind the ‘share’ is much like the idea behind a CSA farm share – where you pay a monthly fee to support a local farm, and in turn receive a weekly veggie share from the season’s crop. The twist here of course is you’re supporting hard working fishermen and you receive a monthly box of quality Alaskan seafood.

There are different sizes and varieties of seafood available from Sitka, all of which change with the season. The seafood ships frozen to your door in vacuum sealed packets and very solid and safe container; in my personal experience, Fedex messed up my delivery and it arrived a few days late, but still perfectly frozen and fine.

A quick note for those worried about frozen seafood – don’t be. Here’s a story I wrote about why everything you’ve heard about frozen fish is wrong; if it’s been frozen correctly of course.

Anyway, Sitka’s packaging is immaculate. The fish is vacuum sealed, then placed in an insulated inner liner along with freezer packs. Be careful opening, this is seriously freezing cold stuff! The whole lot is then packed in a real sturdy cardboard box. I’ve received many boxes since my first 2020 post and every one has arrived in percent condition, with the contents frozen solid.

Sitka Salmon Share salmon and cod
Sitka Salmon Share salmon and cod
Sitka Salmon Share wild Alaskan coho salmon
Sitka Salmon Share wild Alaskan coho salmon
Sitka Salmon Share wild Alaskan cod
Sitka Salmon Share wild Alaskan cod

Your imagination is the only limit with this quality product. Here are two dishes I love to make with fish, both Thai. Firstly cod in a Thai basil sauce with bell peppers. I love cod in this spicy sauce. You need a meaty fish like mahi mahi, swordfish or cod to stand up to the powerful gravy.

Sitka Alaskan cod in Thai basil sauce
Sitka Alaskan cod in Thai basil sauce

Next, Thai Yellow curry with salmon. Buttery and flaky salmon goes so well with this rich and creamy coconut milk based curry. In the picture below I pan fried the salmon skin down until the skin separated. I then cooked the skin and salmon separately so as to turn the skin into a crisp crackling topping – think the salmon version of pork rinds – it’s fabulous! Also a good addition to this dish are Trader Joe’s Thai flavored cashews; crush them down and serve as a spicy, creamy, crunchy finish.

Thai yellow curry with salmon and cashews
Thai yellow curry with salmon and cashews

Looking for even more inspiration? Here are a few more dishes I’ve cooked lately using seafood from Sitka. In order:

  • Sable fish with cous cous and chickpeas – recipe
  • Cod fried rice – recipe
  • Black cod in miso honey sauce with Asian salad and rice – recipe
  • Salmon rogan josh with crisp salmon skin, chickpeas and naan – recipe
  • Panko crusted fish, chips and mushy peas
Sablefish with cous cous
Sablefish with cous cous
Cod fried rice
Cod fried rice
Black cod with miso and honey with Asian salad and rice
Black cod with miso and honey with Asian salad and rice
Rogan josh curry with salmon
Rogan josh curry with salmon
Fish and chips with panko crusted cod
Fish and chips with panko crusted cod

You can shop shares on their site here, prices run $99-$129 a month for a selection of seafood. I ran the math on how that price breaks down to my local grocery store with fresh fish and the price is the same per pound if not better. Don’t forget to use our coupon code GSLC over on the Sitka website for $25 off a premium seafood share. We get a referral fee too, so we can gobble up even more delicious seafood!

Frankly the product here is far better than my local grocery store (yours too perhaps). Alaskan seafood is some of the very best in the world. Alaskan seafood is fished 100% sustainably, heck that’s even written into the state’s constitution. There is literally no mass produced farmed fish in Alaska. You can’t go wrong.

I know European nations often get a lot of attention for their love and care for items like cheese, olive oil, meats and so forth – but Alaskan seafood is really in that bracket. Check out the book “Real Food Fake Food” on Amazon by Larry Olsted where he recommends to always seek out Alaskan seafood for exceptional quality.

If you can’t get quality seafood locally – I’d recommend Sitka without hesitation. The product is impeccable and again, unless you have an amazing local source, I’d be willing to wager you can taste the difference of Sitka’s quality. The fact it will keep for months in the freezer, until you’re ready to cook up a storm – what’s not to love?


Deal alert: use code GSLC over on the Sitka website for $25 off a premium seafood share. We get a referral fee too :)

Leave a Comment